Best Pisa, Siena and San Gimignano Tours Compared
Which Pisa, Siena and San Gimignano day trip from Florence to book: nine GetYourGuide tours compared by lunch, Siena guide, route order, group size and price.
For most first-timers, the lunch option of the Florence: Pisa, Siena and San Gimignano Day Trip with Lunch is the one to book: it covers all three towns in one day from Florence, carries more GetYourGuide reviews than any other tour here, and you sit through the farm lunch stop whichever option you buy. The picks below cover the other eight Pisa, Siena and San Gimignano tours, each with the reason to choose it and its catch.
Check Availability

Which Tour to Book, in Six Picks
Prices are per person for two adults, checked November 20, 2026, for departures between November 21 and 28. Each one is a single option on the listing, so compare the total price of the option you want, not the headline from-price; the price guide has every option side by side. All nine tours show three different sides of Tuscany in one day: a Gothic city, a hill town of towers and the marble Piazza dei Miracoli in Pisa.
- For most first-timers: the featured day trip with lunch, about US$86. It has 4.6/5 from 12,180+ reviews, a 7:45 a.m. start from Villa Costanza and a lunch and tasting at a Chianti farm estate. Add about US$7 for the guided walk in Siena if you want the town explained.
- Most included for under US$110: Pisa, Siena, San Gimignano with Lunch & Winery Experience by VEDITALIA, US$109 for lunch, an English guided walk in Siena and cathedral entry. It runs Pisa first. It has 4.7/5 from 73 reviews, so there are few reviews so far.
- For an English-only guided day: From Florence: Siena, San Gimignano, Pisa & Lunch at Winery by Walkabout, US$148 on the Full Tour. You get a farmhouse lunch with four wines, a Siena guide and cathedral entry, and it leaves from beside Santa Maria Novella station. It carries 4.8/5 from 5,450+ reviews.
- Lowest price with lunch: Florence: Pisa, Siena & San Gimignano with Optional Lunch by Ciaoflorence, US$68 on its Low-Cost option (lunch, no Siena guide). The catch is commentary in several languages at once.
- Smaller group: Florence: Pisa, Siena and San Gimignano Small-Group Day Trip, capped at 21 travelers in a minibus, US$174 (4.9/5 from 23 reviews, few reviews so far). Tuscany in One Day: San Gimignano, Siena, Pisa is My Tour’s smaller minibus group at US$163, with no published cap.
- Private tour with hotel pickup: From Florence: Private Trip to Pisa, San Gimignano, & Siena, US$439 per person when two book (US$878 in total), up to six travelers. The driver is not a city guide, and lunch and entry fees are extra. More on this on the private tours page.
What the Lowest Price Leaves Out
On every tour compared here, the price on the search card is the bottom option, and on the featured trip that means coach and tour leader only. The US$54 seat has no lunch, no Siena guide and no cathedral entry, despite “with Lunch” in the title. The coach still stops at the farm for about 85 minutes, so Low-Cost travelers wait while the others eat. Compare the option you will actually book, not the card price.
Similar names make this harder. Florence: Pisa, Siena, San Gimignano, Chianti Wine & Lunch by MY TOUR SHPK copies the featured trip’s menu and prices but runs Pisa first, and other listings with near-identical titles come from different operators with different meeting points. Check the operator name and the meeting point before you pay.
Good to know: the Siena guide and the cathedral visit on the featured trip are in English only, whatever language you book, and the cathedral option is not sold on Sundays or public holidays.
How the Nine Tours Compare
GetYourGuide ratings, checked November 20, 2026. “Siena guide” means a local guide for the Siena walk; the other stops are free time.
| Tour | Rating | Route | Lunch | Siena guide and cathedral | Group | Meets |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Day Trip with Lunch (My Tour) | 4.6 (12,180+) | Siena first | Higher options | Higher options, English only | Large coach | Villa Costanza, 7:45 a.m. |
| with Light Lunch (Sightseeing Experience) | 4.5 (9,850+) | Pisa first | All but Transfer Only | Guide on one option; tower ticket on another | Large coach | Santa Maria Novella station, 7:30 a.m. |
| Lunch at Winery (Walkabout) | 4.8 (5,450+) | Siena first | Full Tour, four wines | Full Tour | Large coach | Piazza della Stazione 27, 8:00 a.m. |
| with Optional Lunch (Ciaoflorence) | 4.5 (940+) | Siena first | Low-Cost and Full-Day | Guide on Full-Day | Large coach | Piazzale Montelungo, 7:30 a.m. |
| Chianti Wine & Lunch (MY TOUR SHPK) | 4.7 (82) | Pisa first | All options | Higher options, English only | Coach | Villa Costanza |
| Lunch & Winery Experience (VEDITALIA) | 4.7 (73) | Pisa first | Both options | Full Tour, English | Coach | Villa Costanza |
| Small-Group Day Trip (Ciaoflorence) | 4.9 (23) | Not listed | Included | One-hour Siena guide | Up to 21 | On your voucher |
| Tuscany in One Day (My Tour) | 4.4 (3,800+) | Siena first | Included | Included | Smaller minibus | Via dell’Oriuolo, by the Duomo |
| Private Trip (Uniquetuscany) | 5.0 (7) | Pisa, San Gimignano, Siena | Not included | Driver only, no guide | Your party, up to 6 | Your hotel, 9:00 a.m. suggested |
Listings with fewer than 100 reviews are newer or smaller, so their ratings rest on a thin sample. For a full breakdown of each tour, see the tours hub.
Pick by What Matters Most to You
- Climbing the Leaning Tower. No standard option includes it. The light-lunch tour sells a tower ticket option, and Walkabout lists one that was not on sale on the dates checked. You need a timed slot; the what-to-see guide explains how it fits an hour in Pisa.
- Seeing inside Siena Cathedral. Book a full option: My Tour’s Full, VEDITALIA’s Full Tour, Walkabout’s Full Tour or Tuscany in One Day. On the cheaper options you see the cathedral from outside.
- More time in San Gimignano. Walkabout, MY TOUR SHPK and VEDITALIA list 1.5 hours there; the featured trip lists 75 minutes. Free time per stop is set out in the itinerary guide.
- The lunch. Every lunch here is a set meal and a tasting at a farm estate, not a vineyard tour. Tuscany in One Day lists ribollita, lasagna, cantucci with Vin Santo and a tasting of five wines; see tours with lunch for each menu.
- The least time on the coach. The private trip lists 10 hours in total. Among the shared tours, Ciaoflorence’s listed coach legs add up to about 4.5 hours, the featured trip’s to about 5 hours and VEDITALIA’s to about 5 hours 45 minutes.
- Pisa in daylight from November to February. Choose a Pisa-first tour (light lunch, MY TOUR SHPK, VEDITALIA). On Siena-first routes you reach the tower near or after the 4:38 to 4:49 p.m. sunset in mid-November to mid-December. The order may change on the day, so check your confirmation; the best-time guide covers the months.
Booking Recommendations by Traveler
First-timers with one free day and no car. Book the featured trip on its lunch option. The guided Siena walk costs about US$7 more and is the one upgrade most people notice.
Budget couples. The Low-Cost seat (US$54) is the cheapest option of the nine, but you wait during lunch. Ciaoflorence’s lunch option at US$68 costs US$14 more and feeds you.
Older travelers. The shared tours involve stairs, cobbles and walks from the coach park that reviewers put at 10 to 20 minutes each way, and most listings say they are not suitable for wheelchair users. A private driver lets you set the pace, though you still walk the towns.
Wine lovers. Walkabout pours four regional wines with lunch and Tuscany in One Day five, but no tour here is a winery tour. A dedicated Chianti wine trip suits you better.
Travelers who want depth. Pisa is a detour from the hill towns, and forum regulars say San Gimignano deserves two to three hours. If you can skip Pisa, a two-town Siena and San Gimignano day gives longer in Siena; otherwise accept a taste of each.
Travelers who dislike crowds or fixed times. Pick the small-group tour (21 at most) or the private trip. Reviewers on the large tours describe double-decker coaches of 50 or more people, so check the group size before you pay.
Confident drivers. You can drive the loop yourself; read tour vs doing it yourself for the ZTL fines first.
What Lower-Rated Reviewers Complain About
Among lower-rated reviewers (1 to 3 stars) on the three most-reviewed tours, the most common complaint is feeling rushed: one in four on the featured trip and Walkabout, more than a third on the light-lunch tour. After that come late starts and waiting, long hours on the coach, commentary in two or three languages, and the long walk from the coach park. One reviewer on the featured trip booked what they understood as a small group and found themselves on a 175-person tour.
These samples show what can go wrong, not how often. Overall, 1 to 3 star reviews make up at least 7.2% of the featured trip’s reviews, at least 8.6% of the light-lunch tour’s, and 2.8% of Walkabout’s, the lowest of the three, which is also the one guided only in English. The towns rarely disappoint; the pace of the day does. Five-star reviewers most often praise the tour leader.
Is a Pisa, Siena and San Gimignano Tour Worth It?
Yes, if you want all three towns in one day without a car. The three towns sit on different train and bus lines out of Florence, and San Gimignano has no station, so a DIY day means three separate return timetables and only about 1.5 to 2 hours in each town. One coach removes that, and nobody has to skip the wine at lunch to drive. It is the simplest way to see all three in one day without a car, but it is a long, rushed day: if you would rather have time in one town, go there on your own.
Frequently Asked Questions
Which Pisa, Siena and San Gimignano tour is best for first-timers?
The lunch option of the featured day trip by My Tour in Italy suits most first-timers. It has the most reviews of the tours compared here, a 7:45 a.m. start from Villa Costanza and a Chianti farm lunch, and you can add a guided walk in Siena.
What is the cheapest Pisa, Siena and San Gimignano tour?
The featured trip’s Low-Cost option, US$54 on November 20, 2026, is coach and tour leader only. The lowest price that includes lunch was Ciaoflorence’s Low-Cost option at US$68.
Is there a tour with commentary in English only?
Yes. Walkabout’s tour runs in English only. On the featured trip the Siena guide and cathedral visit are in English only, but the tour leader’s commentary on the coach can be in several languages.
Which tour has the smallest group?
The Ciaoflorence small-group day trip is capped at 21 travelers. The private trip carries only your own party, up to six people.
Do any tours include hotel pickup?
Only the private trip picks you up at your hotel in central Florence. The shared tours meet at Villa Costanza, Santa Maria Novella station, Piazzale Montelungo or Via dell’Oriuolo.
Check Dates Before You Choose
Prices and option availability change by date, and the order of stops can change on the day. Check your date in the availability calendar or compare every tour on the homepage.
Choose the Right Pisa, Siena and San Gimignano Tour
For most visitors the Basic option is the one to book: it adds the farm lunch and wine tasting without paying for the guided visits. Choose Full if going inside Siena Cathedral matters to you, or the cheapest option if you only need the coach and will bring your own lunch. Free cancellation up to 24 hours before leaves room to change plans.
Check dates for the Pisa, Siena and San Gimignano day trip